Businesses shunning carbon offsets due to lack of trust, study finds

18th January 2023

A lack of trust in carbon offsets is stalling corporate uptake and potentially pushing net-zero plans off track, a new global survey has found.

The poll of over 500 chief sustainability officers (CSOs) in the UK, US and Canada found that 41% do not use carbon offsets due to trust issues.

Of those who do use carbon credits, 4% don’t validate them at all, 35% only buy from government or voluntary certified schemes, and another 35% undertake their own third-party due diligence, while 43% are exploring working with credit agencies.

This lack of uniformity comes at a time when many carbon offsetting projects are being shown to be inconsistently measured, inadequately monitored, and frequently failing to prove they are based on additional carbon captured.

The survey, which was commissioned by AI specialists AiDash, also found that 56% of CSOs do not have operational control over the majority of their greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.

Commenting on the findings, IEMA’s Deputy CEO, Martin Baxter, said: “This research highlights the relative immaturity of the carbon offsetting market and the associated doubts that some CSOs may have about the effectiveness of some credits.

"It is important for companies to have a good grasp of their own and externalised emissions, and follow IEMA’s GHG Management Hierarchy for reduction.

“Offsetting should always be a last resort. Carbon credits should always be independently verified and sourced from a trusted programme where the measure is certain to be additional, the storage is long term, and there is a low risk of reversal.”

Collating reference data, a lack of common reporting frameworks, and difficulty collating internal information, were the three biggest challenges to net zero identified by the survey, cited by 26%, 19% and 18% of respondents, respectively.

Abhishek Vinod Singh, AiDash CEO, said: “Rather than waiting for governments to agree to regional or global frameworks, businesses are forging forward independently, making ambitious environmental commitments.

“The intent and action is there, but what these businesses desperately need is an organisational tool they can trust to accurately measure, monitor, track and validate the progress of their sustainability plans on their journey to net zero.”

Image credit: Unsplash

Transform articles

Web exclusive: Environmental Outcomes Reports consultation – more than meets the eye

Josh Fothergill, FIEMA, CEnv, explores some strategic questions we should all ask of the UK government’s Environmental Outcomes Reports consultation, which are not immediately apparent from reading the consultation itself.

22nd March 2023

Read more

Global greenhouse gas emissions continue to rise, but there is still time to avoid irreversible damage to the environment, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) revealed yesterday.

20th March 2023

Read more

Jeremy Hunt unveiled a raft of environmental commitments during his first budget this afternoon, including huge boosts for nuclear energy and carbon capture and storage (CCS).

15th March 2023

Read more

One of IEMA’s corporate partners, Qualis Flow, has been nominated for The Earthshot Prize 2023, putting it in contention for one of five £1m prizes.

14th March 2023

Read more

Most UK businesses strongly support environmental regulation, with just one-fifth believing that the current rules are excessive, a new survey has found.

3rd March 2023

Read more

A new framework developed by IEMA to help businesses act on biodiversity loss and contribute towards nature restoration has officially launched today.

1st March 2023

Read more

More than three-quarters of Europe’s top 50 companies are linking carbon reduction targets to executive pay, a new study by PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) has uncovered.

28th February 2023

Read more

Fossil fuel companies are enticing huge numbers of workers away from renewable energy firms with the promise of high salaries and perks, a new global study has uncovered.

15th February 2023

Read more

Media enquires

Looking for an expert to speak at an event or comment on an item in the news?

Find an expert