RSPB loses judicial review

27th January 2022

In R. (on the application of RSPB) v Natural England, the RSPB and a nature conservation scientist appealed a Natural England decision to grant a licence to “take and disturb” hen harriers for scientific, research or educational purposes under the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981.

Hen harriers are a rare bird species and enjoy the highest level of statutory protection. Under EU Directive 2009/147, EU member states are required to designate special protection areas (SPAs) for their conservation. There are two SPAs in England.

Hen harriers feed grouse chicks to their young, and individuals seeking to maximise grouse numbers for shooting were killing harriers and destroying their nests. Criminal enforcement had limited effect. In 2015, Natural England recommended piloting a brood management scheme in which eggs and chicks would be removed from nests, reared in captivity and released into a suitable habitat away from grouse moors.

On receipt of a licence application in 2017, Natural England produced a Habitats Regulations Assessment in accordance with the Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations 2017, identifying a potential decrease in breeding and juvenile survival as the trial’s principal risk; it suggested potential mitigation. It completed a Technical Assessment, concluding that there was no satisfactory alternative to the trial. The first licence was granted in January 2018.

Previous judicial proceedings claimed that Natural England was wrong to consider the application only in terms of research, and that it failed to consider hen harrier conservation.

It was alleged that Natural England should have considered satisfactory alternatives to brood management, not just alternatives to the trial.

A judge held that the 1981 Act required Natural England to consider only whether there were other satisfactory solutions to the scientific purpose, and that it had granted the licence lawfully. The judge declined to find that Natural England was protecting the grouse moor industry and concluded that Natural England had been entitled to find that the scientific trial would not adversely affect the SPAs’ integrity.

The appellants claimed the judge had been wrong to look at the research element while ignoring hen harrier conservation. They believed the judge should have considered Section 16(1) of the Act, which said “no other satisfactory solution” – meaning the broader objective of the EU Directive, not just the specific derogation. They also submitted that the decision was incompatible with Sections 16(1) and 16(A1), criminalising and preventing hen harrier persecution.

On appeal, it was concluded that the judge had been correct to find that Natural England had properly considered the application as being for permission to carry out a research project within the Act, rather than conservation. The judge found the Act’s structure and wording to be clear, that the “purpose” for which “other satisfactory solutions” had to be considered was the purpose for which the licence was sought, and that Natural England had been required to consider alternative solutions for the evidence-gathering process, not alternative conservation techniques.

They also confirmed that brood management was not designed to displace hen harriers but reduce their persecution; that brood management was not unlawful or contrary to SPA integrity; and that the trial was temporary and unlikely to involve many interventions in SPAs.

The appeal was dismissed.

Image Credit | Shutterstock


Subscribe to IEMA's newsletters to receive timely articles, expert opinions, event announcements, and much more, directly in your inbox.

Transform articles

The biophilic effect

Vanessa Champion reveals how biophilic design can help you meet your environmental, social and governance goals

4th April 2024

Read more

Regulatory gaps between the EU and UK are beginning to appear, warns Neil Howe in this edition’s environmental legislation round-up

4th April 2024

Read more

Five of the latest books on the environment and sustainability

3rd April 2024

Read more

A hangover from EU legislation, requirements on the need for consideration of nutrient neutrality for developments on many protected sites in England were nearly removed from the planning system in 2023.

2nd April 2024

Read more

The UK’s new biodiversity net gain (BNG) requirements could create 15,000 hectares of woodlands, heath, grasslands, and wetlands and absorb 650,000 tonnes of carbon each year.

13th March 2024

Read more

All major housing developments in England will be required by law to deliver at least a 10% increase in biodiversity under new rules that came into force today.

12th February 2024

Read more

As we approach the 40th anniversary of the Born Free Foundation, co-founder Will Travers OBE tells Chris Seekings how a new approach to conservation is needed to end animal suffering

1st February 2024

Read more

Ajirioghene Samuel looks at some exciting tree-planting initiatives, offering nature-based solutions to climate change impacts

1st February 2024

Read more

Media enquires

Looking for an expert to speak at an event or comment on an item in the news?

Find an expert

IEMA Cookie Notice

Clicking the ‘Accept all’ button means you are accepting analytics and third-party cookies. Our website uses necessary cookies which are required in order to make our website work. In addition to these, we use analytics and third-party cookies to optimise site functionality and give you the best possible experience. To control which cookies are set, click ‘Settings’. To learn more about cookies, how we use them on our website and how to change your cookie settings please view our cookie policy.

Manage cookie settings

Our use of cookies

You can learn more detailed information in our cookie policy.

Some cookies are essential, but non-essential cookies help us to improve the experience on our site by providing insights into how the site is being used. To maintain privacy management, this relies on cookie identifiers. Resetting or deleting your browser cookies will reset these preferences.

Essential cookies

These are cookies that are required for the operation of our website. They include, for example, cookies that enable you to log into secure areas of our website.

Analytics cookies

These cookies allow us to recognise and count the number of visitors to our website and to see how visitors move around our website when they are using it. This helps us to improve the way our website works.

Advertising cookies

These cookies allow us to tailor advertising to you based on your interests. If you do not accept these cookies, you will still see adverts, but these will be more generic.

Save and close