MPs criticise ‘lopsided’ plans to prevent investment funds from greenwashing

14th March 2023


The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) must do more to tackle investment funds that have misled customers with exaggerated sustainability claims, and not punish victims, a cross-party group of MPs has said.

Under current proposals to tackle greenwashing, consumers who invest in funds found guilty of the practice may have to pay to move their investments into new sustainable funds.

However, the Treasury Sub-Committee on Financial Services Regulations is concerned that the FCA has not put a figure on how much this will cost, and has now called on the regulator to conduct a more detailed cost-benefit analysis.

The MPs have also asked the regulator what enforcement work it will be doing to tackle funds who have misled consumers following revelations that some ‘sustainable’ investments have gone to oil and gas giants Shell and ExxonMobil.

“Consumers who invested in funds believing they were doing their bit to save the planet must not be made to bear the cost of moving if they find out their fund isn’t so green after all,” said Harriett Baldwin, chair of the committee.

“Without a comprehensive cost-benefit analysis, the regulator’s proposals are lopsided. Further work on what the costs are going to be, who will pay, and how the regulator will enforce the rules, is clearly necessary.”

The FCA is looking to introduce criteria that an investment fund would need to meet to describe itself as ‘sustainable’, ‘ESG’, ‘green’, or similar.

It assumes that around one-third of funds currently claiming to be sustainable would no longer qualify under its new criteria, and another third would decide not to use the label.

As a result, the Treasury Committee has also asked the regulator whether there is a risk that tighter regulations could drive funds away from ESG investing, or out of the UK, reducing consumer choice.

This comes after research by climate solutions provider South Pole last year found that a quarter of large companies have decided not to publicise their net-zero targets, which has raised fears that many are now greenhushing.

CEO, Renat Heuberger, said: “Businesses are increasingly backing up their targets with science-based emissions reductions milestones. But if a quarter aren't coming forward with details on what makes their target credible, could corporate greenhushing be spreading?

“The speed at which we are overshooting our planetary boundaries is mind-blowing. More than ever, we need the companies making progress on sustainability to inspire their peers to make a start. This is impossible if progress is happening in silence.”

Image credit: Shutterstock


Transform articles

New regulations

This legislative update has been provided by Cedrec Information Systems Ltd, available at cedrec.com. In Partnership with Barbour EHS.

1st June 2023

Read more

In Sunbeam Fishing Ltd v Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, the owner and operator of a sandeel fishing vessel argued that the secretary of state’s decision was unlawful in both substance and timing, and sought to ensure the same illegalities would not affect the UK fleet’s ability to catch sandeel in 2023.

31st May 2023

Read more

Anglian Water has been fined £2.65m after pleading guilty at Chelmsford Magistrates’ Court to allowing millions of litres of untreated sewage to overflow into the North Sea.

31st May 2023

Read more

In February, the House of Lords began a consultation on the impact of environmental regulations on development.

31st May 2023

Read more

UK ministers have published a list of 600 EU laws that the government plans to scrap by the end of the year following Brexit, including 341 environmental laws.

31st May 2023

Read more

Water companies could be hit with “unlimited fines” for polluting the environment under a new plan unveiled by the UK government today.

4th April 2023

Read more

As PFAS seep into the public consciousness (and bloodstream), Chris Seekings reports on what’s being done to regulate them

30th March 2023

Read more

Media enquires

Looking for an expert to speak at an event or comment on an item in the news?

Find an expert