How EIA positively influences project design

30th April 2013


Related Topics

Related tags

  • Ecodesign ,
  • Consultancy ,
  • Construction ,
  • Local government

Author

IEMA

Clare du Heaume, from Parsons Brinckerhoff, describes the benefits environmental impact assessment (EIA) can bring to the development design process

The EIA process, whether or not it results in a statutory environmental statement, has traditionally been seen by some parts of the development sector as just another hoop to jump through in getting a project delivered.

EIA was sometimes considered as the proverbial “spanner in the works” when the masterplan or design was close to completion, complicating things through the introduction of unexpected environmental mitigation measures which could compromise the intended design.

Even the term “environmental constraint” has negative connotations, implying that an environmental feature can only have a negative influence on the scheme design.

The reality is that EIA needs to be considered as a key part of the evolution of a scheme, benefiting the design of a development. If done well, the process of identifying environmental mitigation requirements can improve the integrity, design, feasibility and even value of the final scheme design. For example, ecological mitigation requirements can add to the aesthetic quality of a development for the end user.

Building better homes

Housing schemes are classic examples of how design informed by EIA is often an improvement on an original vision.

In one case that Parsons Brinckerhoff worked on, a local planning authority had allocated a site for a certain number of residential units in its local development plan.

The EIA process identified a number of environmental features on the site which meant that the allocated housing density was not possible.

The incorporation of mitigation requirements in the masterplan, including ecological and flooding compensation areas and the retention of mature trees, reduced the number of houses able to be included.

However, reduced housing density, more open space and a better connection with the natural world resulted in a more attractive development, driving values up and, most importantly, allowed planning permission to be secured.

By considering the environmental factors together in a structured way for the EIA, it was easier to reach a design that integrated mitigation into the scheme and created a much more pleasant environment in which to live.

Protecting assets

Key environmental features, identified through early surveys for a proposed business park provided the starting point for individual site selection and the subsequent masterplan.

As a result, an area of high potential for important archaeology was avoided through choice of an alternative site for initial development.

The retention and provision of a lighting and habitat buffer for a woodland bat foraging corridor was part of the design concept. This meant that mitigation was effectively built in to the design.

Getting buy-in

Good environmental design also has benefits for the developer in terms of stakeholder relationships and project approval.

A highway improvement scheme had several road layout options.

The flood modelling process, carried out as part of the EIA, identified that one of these options would have caused unacceptable flooding, as well as potentially be subject to flooding itself.

Another option would have crossed a site of special scientific interest.

Both of these options were subsequently dropped as being unfeasible due to environmental considerations, resulting in an alternative option that was more readily accepted by statutory bodies, local residents and the public.

This project also demonstrated how early identification of unfeasible design options can save the developer time, money and effort in trying to promote an unfeasible scheme.

Environmental considerations can often add to the end users’ enjoyment of a development.

Retention and enhancement of existing landscape features such as hedgerows, woodland, or mature trees can, for example, improve the character of a business park (see figure 1), or enhance the driver’s view from a highway.

The preservation and restoration of a listed building or historic feature may add an interesting feature to a new railway station. Meanwhile, the creation of wildlife habitat can improve the quality of a housing development.

Figure 1: Good use of existing landscape features is integral to a well designed business park.

The identification of environmental features through the EIA process can positively influence the design of a development, both for the developer and the end user by responding to local character and features.

Each stage of the masterplanning or design process should be an improvement on the previous design, having incorporated changes identified through EIA.


This article was written as a contribution to the EIA Quality Mark’s commitment to improving EIA practice.

Clare du Heaume is a senior environmental consultant at Parsons Brinckerhoff


Transform articles

Nature Recovery Green Paper must focus on the real issues

In March, Defra launched the consultation on its Nature Recovery Green Paper, which set out pro-posals to deliver the 30/30 targets (30% of land and sea to be protected by 2030), protect species and deliver nature recovery.

26th May 2022

Read more

Defra kickstarted 2022 with its January consultation on biodiversity net gain (BNG) regulations and im-plementation.

26th May 2022

Read more

Social impact assessment (SIA) is a key area of impact assessment practice. It has been described by the International Association of Impact Assessment as the process of identifying and managing the social issues of project development, and includes the effective engagement of affected communities in participatory processes of identification, assessment and management of social impacts.

26th May 2022

Read more

The Office for Environmental Protection (OEP) ran a consultation earlier this year to gather stakeholders’ views and insights on its strategy and enforcement policy.

26th May 2022

Read more

Volume 12 of our Impact Assessment Outlook Journal brings together articles on strategic impact assessment to inspire practitioners.

24th March 2022

Read more

Henry Collin discusses the relevance of COP26’s outcomes for nature and biodiversity in the UK

9th March 2022

Read more

IEMA has published updated guidance to help environmental impact assessment (EIA) practitioners better understand, record and reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from major developments.

1st March 2022

Read more

IEMA has today published new guidance for environmental impact assessment (EIA) practitioners to better assess and manage the effects of development on land and soils, and ensure sustainable outcomes.

17th February 2022

Read more

In the development of major projects, it is important to consider greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions through environmental impact assessment (EIA) during the consenting and planning process.

27th January 2022

Read more

Media enquires

Looking for an expert to speak at an event or comment on an item in the news?

Find an expert