Case law >> Identical development ensures EIA compliance

6th December 2013


Related Topics

Related tags

  • Consultancy ,
  • Construction

Author

Donald McQueen

Jen Hawkins from LexisPSL describes a High Court ruling that upheld a decision to grant planning permission for a housing development despite failure to screen plans

In Gibson v Harrow LBC and Parish of St George Headstone [2013] EWHC 3449, the High Court upheld planning permission for a housing development, despite the failure by the local authority to screen it.

In Gibson, four separate planning applications were made for a housing development; three were refused, but the fourth was granted permission.

Although permission was refused for the third application, it had undergone an environmental impact assessment (EIA) screening assessment and it was declared that the development did not require an EIA.

The fourth application was for an identical development, but without a previously identified defect in the planning obligation submitted with the application. The decision to grant permission was challenged on two main grounds: failure to screen the application; and failure to register the screening direction.

Reg 7 of the EIA Regulations (read together with reg 5) says a screening assessment should be carried out to determine whether an EIA is required. Although the fourth application for planning permission was new, it related to a development which, in its physical dimensions, characteristics and impact on the environment, was identical to the third application. Therefore, there was no obligation on the authority to carry out a further screening assessment.

Reg 23(1) requires a copy of a screening opinion to be placed on the planning register. The authority admitted it had failed to comply with this obligation. The court granted relief in respect of this breach because the failure to place the opinion on the register did not affect the decision to grant planning permission.


Transform articles

Costs limit application for individual in ‘Save the Northern Meadows’ group granted

In R. (on the application of Lewis) v Welsh Ministers, following a costs order against the claimant, the claimant applied for a costs limit in accordance with the Aarhus Convention 2001 and the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) 1998/3132.

26th May 2022

Read more

Multinational drinks giant Diageo has been fined more than £1.2m by the Scottish government for breaches relating to the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS), despite having an appeal partially up-held.

26th May 2022

Read more

The Office for Environmental Protection (OEP) has today published its first monitoring report on the UK government’s 25 Year Environment Plan, warning that progress so far has been “slow”.

12th May 2022

Read more

US companies registered with the Security and Exchange Commission (SEC) could be forced to report the climate-related impacts of their business under plans announced by the regulator this week.

24th March 2022

Read more

In R. (on the application of Finch) v Surrey County Council, the appellant appealed against the dismissal of her judicial review claim. She sought review of the council planning authority’s decision to grant permission to expand an oil well site and drill four new oil wells.

24th March 2022

Read more

Yorkshire Water has agreed to pay £300,000 to Yorkshire Wildlife Trust following a sewage discharge incident in Leeds in 2018.

24th March 2022

Read more

Nearly 10,400 companies worldwide – worth $105trn (£80.4trn) in market capitalisation – will be asked to disclose environmental data by more than 680 financial institutions this year through CDP.

14th March 2022

Read more

In R. (on the application of RSPB) v Natural England, the RSPB and a nature conservation scientist appealed a Natural England decision to grant a licence to “take and disturb” hen harriers for scientific, research or educational purposes under the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981.

27th January 2022

Read more

Thames Water Utilities Limited has been fined £4m for discharging half a million litres of sewage into Seacourt Stream and Hinksey Stream in Oxford over two days in July 2016.

27th January 2022

Read more

Media enquires

Looking for an expert to speak at an event or comment on an item in the news?

Find an expert