Appeal dismissed against environmental permit decision

31st January 2020


Web waste to incinerator shutterstock 497531182

Related Topics

Related tags

  • Pollution & Waste Management ,
  • Waste

Author

IEMA

A local action group appealed to the Crown Court after its claim for judicial review was dismissed when it challenged the validity of an environmental permit granted by the Environment Agency.

The permit had been granted for the operation of a waste incineration plant, but there was a scientific error in the application submitted by the operator. The appellant challenged the lawfulness of the permit as a result of the error. The appeal was dismissed, as the judge ruled that the error did not affect the lawfulness of the Agency's decision.

The judge considered four key issues – firstly, whether the permit incorporated the error. Including an incorrect statement in an application document was not evidence of the same error being made by the Agency in making its decision. Secondly, the appellant argued that the judge had relied on the Agency's retrospective explanation after the fact. As a regulator, the Agency used its own scientific and technical expertise to inform its decisions, and there was no failure of its expertise in this case.

Thirdly, they considered whether the judge had failed to investigate the need for a dust management plan. It was ruled that it was not for the court to ask why a plan was required. The final ground of appeal was based on the margin of appreciation. The judge ruled that the Agency had lawfully exercised its judgement and that the judge did not have to rely on establishing an enhanced margin of error for such regulators.

There was no evidence that the Agency itself made a mistake or was influenced by the mistake, or had failed to exercise its knowledge and expertise. The appeal was dismissed, as it was not for the court to explore the scientific integrity of the Agency's assessment.

Picture credit: Shutterstock


Transform articles

The dirty face of beauty

Lorraine Dallmeier unmasks the environmental impact of the cosmetics industry

28th September 2023

Read more

From eliminating single-use plastics and cutting emissions, to building resilience to pandemics, the list of sustainability issues the NHS has to contend with is endless. Heidi Barnard, PIEMA, head of sustainability at NHS Supply Chain, tells Chris Seekings how she tackles them.

28th September 2023

Read more

With 90% of the world’s goods transported by ship, the maritime industry is confronting major challenges to safety and supply. Huw Morris reports

28th September 2023

Read more

The UK government and water regulators may have broken the law over untreated sewage discharges made last year, the Office for Environmental Protection (OEP) has said today.

12th September 2023

Read more

The UK government has unveiled plans to relax “defective” EU-derived laws on nutrient pollution in order to boost house building.

30th August 2023

Read more

The UK government has announced that new rules to ensure packaging producers pay for the cost of recycling their products will be deferred by a year to October 2025.

26th July 2023

Read more

The majority of UK adults think that the phase out of petrol-fuelled cars is due to happen sooner than is actually the case, new polling has uncovered.

13th July 2023

Read more

Media enquires

Looking for an expert to speak at an event or comment on an item in the news?

Find an expert